Hipkins challenges Luxon to a debate on health
In this story Christopher Luxon, Labour Party, National Party, Chris Hipkins

Labour leader Chris Hipkins has challenged National leader Christopher Luxon to a debate regarding the health sector. This follows a Stuff poll finding that voters believe Hipkins understands their lives and promises better than Luxon.
Key facts
4 facts
- Stuff Pulse of the Nation survey conducted with Ideally included 616 voters

- 48% of voters believe Hipkins understands their family issues compared to 24% for Luxon

- 59.1% of respondents trust Hipkins to deliver on promises, while 33.8% trust Luxon

- 47% of voters believe Hipkins would do a better job as prime minister than Luxon

The full story
1 min read · 4 outlets
A Stuff Pulse of the Nation survey found Chris Hipkins is leading Christopher Luxon 2:1 regarding whether voters believe he understands their lives. When asked which leader better understood the issues facing their families, 48% of respondents chose Hipkins while 24% chose Luxon.![]()
The survey also indicated that Hipkins holds a 25-point lead in trust. Specifically, 59.1% of the 616 voters surveyed trusted Hipkins either a 'great deal' or a 'fair amount', whereas only 33.8% felt the same about Luxon. Conversely, 62.2% of respondents said they trusted Luxon 'not very much' or 'not at all' to deliver on his promises.![]()
Regarding performance as prime minister, 47% of respondents believe Hipkins would do a better job than Luxon, while 21% believe he would do a worse job. This sentiment varied by income, with 57% of households earning under $75,000 believing Hipkins would do a better job, compared to 34% of households earning over $150,000.![]()
In a separate development, Hipkins has challenged Luxon to a debate specifically on the state of the health system. Hipkins stated the system is 'in crisis' and invited Luxon to discuss the issue.![]()
How it developed
- Mon 19 Oct, 6:39pmChris Hipkins issued a social media challenge to Christopher Luxon to debate the health system.

Where reports differ
Compiled from reports by Stuff, RNZ, The Post and 1News.
How they headlined it
-
StuffPulse of the Nation: Kiwis think Hipkins understands their lives more than Luxon (opens in new tab)
- Pulse of the Nation: Hipkins more trusted to deliver promises than Luxon (opens in new tab)
- Do voters think Chris Hipkins would do a better or worse job as PM? (opens in new tab)
- Pulse of the Nation: Do voters think Hipkins would do a better or worse job than Luxon as PM? (opens in new tab)
- Do voters think Hipkins would do better or worse than Luxon as PM? (opens in new tab)
-
RNZHipkins challenges Christopher Luxon to debate on health (opens in new tab)
Also on NZ Herald (opens in new tab)
-
The PostLabour and National are fighting. Someone else is winning (opens in new tab)
-
1NewsFull video: Labour's Chris Hipkins speaks to media after perilous poll (opens in new tab)