Hipkins challenges Luxon to a debate on health

StuffRNZNZ HeraldThe Post1NewsMonday 19 October 2026 · 5 outlets · 8 reports · updated

In this story Christopher Luxon, Labour Party, National Party, Chris Hipkins

Photo: 1News (opens in new tab)

Labour leader Chris Hipkins has challenged National leader Christopher Luxon to a debate regarding the health sector. This follows a Stuff poll finding that voters believe Hipkins understands their lives and promises better than Luxon.

Key facts

4 facts
  • Stuff Pulse of the Nation survey conducted with Ideally included 616 votersStuff
  • 48% of voters believe Hipkins understands their family issues compared to 24% for LuxonStuff
  • 59.1% of respondents trust Hipkins to deliver on promises, while 33.8% trust LuxonStuff
  • 47% of voters believe Hipkins would do a better job as prime minister than LuxonStuff

The full story

1 min read · 4 outlets

A Stuff Pulse of the Nation survey found Chris Hipkins is leading Christopher Luxon 2:1 regarding whether voters believe he understands their lives. When asked which leader better understood the issues facing their families, 48% of respondents chose Hipkins while 24% chose Luxon.Stuff

The survey also indicated that Hipkins holds a 25-point lead in trust. Specifically, 59.1% of the 616 voters surveyed trusted Hipkins either a 'great deal' or a 'fair amount', whereas only 33.8% felt the same about Luxon. Conversely, 62.2% of respondents said they trusted Luxon 'not very much' or 'not at all' to deliver on his promises.Stuff

Regarding performance as prime minister, 47% of respondents believe Hipkins would do a better job than Luxon, while 21% believe he would do a worse job. This sentiment varied by income, with 57% of households earning under $75,000 believing Hipkins would do a better job, compared to 34% of households earning over $150,000.Stuff

In a separate development, Hipkins has challenged Luxon to a debate specifically on the state of the health system. Hipkins stated the system is 'in crisis' and invited Luxon to discuss the issue.RNZ

How it developed

  • Mon 19 Oct, 6:39pmChris Hipkins issued a social media challenge to Christopher Luxon to debate the health system.RNZ

Where reports differ

  • One report notes a 13-point lead for Hipkins as preferred prime minister, while another Verian poll shows Luxon leading Hipkins 20% to 17%The Post1News

Compiled from reports by Stuff, RNZ, The Post and 1News.

How they headlined it

First reported by Stuff, Mon 19 Oct, 7:58am · 8 reports from 4 outlets over 2 days
  1. StuffStuff

    Pulse of the Nation: Kiwis think Hipkins understands their lives more than Luxon (opens in new tab)

  2. RNZRNZ

    Hipkins challenges Christopher Luxon to debate on health (opens in new tab)

    Also on NZ Herald (opens in new tab)

  3. The PostThe Post

    Labour and National are fighting. Someone else is winning (opens in new tab)

  4. 1News1News

    Full video: Labour's Chris Hipkins speaks to media after perilous poll (opens in new tab)