Justice secretary will not resign following scathing ministry review

StuffThe Post1NewsRNZThursday 12 November 2026 · 4 outlets · 5 reports · updated

In this story Paul Goldsmith, Public Service Commission, Ministry of Justice

Photo: 1News (opens in new tab)

Justice secretary Andrew Kibblewhite has refused to step down after an independent review criticised the Ministry of Justice's handling of former employee Russell Harrison. The review found that Harrison received between $500,000 and $550,000 in full pay during a five-year suspension.

Key facts

3 facts
  • Russell Harrison received $500,000 to $550,000 in salary while suspended on full payThe PostStuff
  • The review was ordered by Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith in AugustStuffThe Post1NewsRNZ
  • Harrison pleaded guilty to money laundering and was sentenced to ten months detention or community serviceStuffThe Post

The full story

1 min read · 4 outlets

An independent review has identified significant leadership, decision-making, and accountability issues within the Ministry of Justice. The investigation was prompted by the ministry's handling of former Lotto presenter Russell Harrison, who remained on full pay for five years while facing criminal charges.StuffThe Post1News

Harrison was suspended on full pay for five years, receiving between $500,000 and $550,000 in taxpayer-funded salary. He had been employed as a Family Court navigator for only two weeks before being arrested in 2021 following a global FBI sting involving the delivery of gold bars to a motorcycle gang.StuffThe Post

The review found that senior leaders, including Secretary for Justice Andrew Kibblewhite and chief operating officer Carl Crafar, accepted flawed internal legal advice that prevented disciplinary action until criminal matters were resolved. Reviewers noted that the ministry appeared more concerned with avoiding legal error than with public trust or taxpayer interests.The Post1NewsStuff

The Public Service Commission also found the ministry was under intense pressure, with staff reporting they were overworked, exhausted, and lacked clear strategic direction. While the review highlighted systemic issues, Kibblewhite stated he would not resign, noting, “I think mistakes were made, but we’ve owned them, we’ve fixed them and we’re learning from it”.StuffRNZ

How it developed

  • Thu 12 Nov, 4:37pmThe review also highlighted broader systemic issues including an exhausted workforce and a lack of clear strategic direction within the ministry.RNZ

Where reports differ

  • Reports vary on Harrison's sentence, citing ten months detention in one report and community service in anotherStuff

Compiled from reports by Stuff, The Post, 1News and RNZ.

How they headlined it

First reported by Stuff, Thu 12 Nov, 11:07am · 5 reports from 4 outlets over 6 hours
  1. StuffStuff

    Damning report slams Justice officials over handling of ex- Lotto host employment case (opens in new tab)

  2. The PostThe Post

    Scathing review skewers justice bosses over five-year suspension of gang-linked former TV star (opens in new tab)

  3. 1News1News via RNZ

    'Sobering': Ex-Lotto presenter review finds swathe of issues at ministry (opens in new tab)

  4. RNZRNZ

    Ministry of Justice staff describe 'fluffy' strategy, exhausted workforce (opens in new tab)