Insurer ordered to pay Kiwi traveller after acting in bad faith

NZ HeraldRNZStuffThursday 12 November 2026 · 3 outlets · 3 reports · updated

In this story Air New Zealand

Photo: NZ Herald (opens in new tab)

An ombudsman has ruled that a travel insurer acted in bad faith after a woman became seriously ill in Bali. The insurer suggested the traveller hide her medical condition from an airline to reduce costs. The woman was awarded $5,000 plus the cost of her business class flights.

Key facts

3 facts
  • The IFSO Scheme ruled an insurer acted in bad faith regarding a claim for a traveller in BaliNZ HeraldStuff
  • The insurer was ordered to pay $5000 for special inconvenienceNZ HeraldRNZStuff
  • The insurer breached the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 and Consumer Guarantees Act 1993NZ HeraldStuff

The full story

1 min read · 3 outlets

An ombudsman has ruled that a travel insurer acted in bad faith and risked a customer's health to reduce costs. The Insurance and Financial Services Ombudsman Scheme (IFSO Scheme) found the insurer suggested a seriously ill traveller hide her medical condition from an airline. This occurred after Air New Zealand's medical team stated the traveller required a nurse or doctor as a medical escort to fly home from Bali.NZ HeraldRNZStuff

The traveller, whose name is suppressed for privacy, had originally booked an Air New Zealand Economy Skycouch to lie flat. An insurer representative told her she was fit to fly alone and suggested she book business class with a different airline without disclosing her health issues. The traveller instead asked a former paramedic to fly to Bali to assist her, booking cheaper business-class flights for both.NZ HeraldRNZStuff

During the flight to Sydney, the traveller suffered a medical emergency and was hospitalised upon arrival, necessitating new flights to New Zealand. The insurer initially only paid an amount equivalent to an Economy Skycouch seat and declined costs for the companion and rebooked flights.NZ HeraldRNZStuff

The IFSO Scheme upheld a complaint and ordered the insurer to pay $5000 for special inconvenience, the companion's business-class fare, and the rebooked flights from Sydney. Ombudsman Karen Stevens said, "This directly risked Cara’s health in order to reduce costs". The scheme found the insurer materially breached fair conduct obligations under the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013.NZ HeraldRNZStuff

Where reports differ

  • One report specifies the rebooked flights were to Christchurch, while others only mention New ZealandRNZStuff

Compiled from reports by NZ Herald, RNZ and Stuff.

How they headlined it

First reported by NZ Herald, Thu 12 Nov, 1:36pm · 3 reports from 3 outlets over 19 hours
  1. NZ HeraldNZ Herald

    Seriously ill Kiwi traveller awarded $5000 payout after insurer found to have acted in bad faith (opens in new tab)

  2. RNZRNZ

    Insurer told traveller not to disclose medical condition (opens in new tab)

  3. StuffStuff

    Travel insurer told sick tourist in Bali to hide medical condition from airline (opens in new tab)