Police say diary of deceased Kiwi monk shows no plans to leave island

StuffOtago Daily TimesNZ HeraldThe Press1NewsMonday 16 November 2026 · 5 outlets · 5 reports · updated
Photo: Otago Daily Times (opens in new tab)

Local police say diary entries from Justin Evans, a 24-year-old Christchurch man, do not indicate he planned to leave Papa Stronsay. Evans, known as Brother Ignatius, went missing from the Golgotha Monastery in April before his body was found in the water near the remote Scottish island.

Key facts

1 fact
  • Justin Evans, 24, disappeared from Papa Stronsay in April and his body was found on 6 MayStuffOtago Daily TimesNZ HeraldThe Press1News

The full story

1 min read · 5 outlets

A BBC Scotland documentary has revealed that digital diary entries belonging to Justin Evans, a 24-year-old monk from Christchurch, showed no indication he intended to leave the island or take his own life. The entries, which discussed his theological views and feelings, included plans for future religious services and meetings. PC Piotr Kampinowski stated, “That information goes to show us that perhaps his disappearance wasn’t something that was planned because he was already looking into the future of his life at the monastery”.StuffOtago Daily TimesNZ HeraldThe Press1News

Evans, also known as Brother Ignatius, disappeared from the Golgotha Monastery on the Orkney island of Papa Stronsay shortly before midnight on 11 April. His body was recovered from the sea on 6 May near the island of Stronsay. Investigators found no marks or injuries on his body to suggest foul play.StuffOtago Daily TimesNZ HeraldThe Press1News

The Sons of the Most Holy Redeemer, also known as the Transalpine Redemptorists, have links to New Zealand through a monastery near Geraldine. Following his death, the religious order stated that Evans was presumed to have drowned, though they noted the circumstances of his death remain a mystery.StuffOtago Daily TimesNZ HeraldThe Press1News

Police Scotland concluded there were no suspicious circumstances surrounding the death, and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service determined that no further action was required. An officer involved in the investigation described Evans as a "sensitive soul" whose past had been weighing on him.StuffOtago Daily TimesNZ HeraldThe Press1News

Compiled from reports by Stuff, Otago Daily Times, NZ Herald, The Press and 1News.

How they headlined it

First reported by Stuff, Mon 16 Nov, 11:15am · 5 reports from 5 outlets over 5 hours
  1. StuffStuff

    Mystery surrounds death of NZ monk as diary reveals plans for future (opens in new tab)

  2. Otago Daily TimesOtago Daily Times

    Documentary sheds new light on investigation into dead NZ monk’s diary entries (opens in new tab)

  3. NZ HeraldNZ Herald

    Diary of dead Kiwi monk Justin Evans at centre of police probe (opens in new tab)

  4. The PressThe Press via RNZ

    'Had plans for the future': Diary of dead Kiwi monk Justin Evans at centre of police probe (opens in new tab)

  5. 1News1News via RNZ

    'Plans for the future': Diary of dead Kiwi monk in police probe (opens in new tab)