US ambassador rebukes Wayne Brown over democracy comments
In this story Labour Party, National Party, Wayne Brown, New Zealand Government

United States Ambassador Jared Novelly has criticised Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown after the mayor suggested democracy has "had its day". Brown made the remarks following a business trip to China, suggesting New Zealand should consider different models. Brown has also denied claims by a councillor that he was compromised during his visit.
Key facts
3 facts
The full story
1 min read · 6 outlets
Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown has faced criticism after stating that democracy has "had its day". Following a six-city tour of China, Brown suggested that New Zealand's Mixed Member Proportional electoral system is not working and that it is time to "try something else". He argued that while New Zealand and the US lack true capitalism, China's model of "centrally managed capitalism" allows for brutal competition and lets businesses fail.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
The US Ambassador to New Zealand, Jared Novelly, issued a social media rebuke to the mayor, starting his response with "Ok, Boomer!". Novelly questioned the mayor's intelligence, suggesting he had not "made the cut" for an intelligence briefing, and defended democratic systems by comparing them to Auckland's traffic lights.![]()
![]()
![]()
Brown defended his comments by stating he was not advocating for China's Communist system, but rather suggesting New Zealand learn from its economic success. He claimed that over the last 40 years, Labour and National have presided over the decay of the New Zealand economy. He also criticised the recent election process, describing it as a "horror story" and suggesting the MMP system can be "gamed".![]()
![]()
![]()
The mayor has rejected suggestions from councillor John Watson that he was "compromised" by the Chinese government during his trip. Brown described the idea of being captured by China as "laughable" and "xenophobic". He noted that China is one of New Zealand's largest trading partners and that a report regarding his trip will be published by the end of the month.![]()
How it developed
- Wed 18 Nov, 5:00pmWayne Brown denied allegations from councillor John Watson that he had been compromised by the Chinese government during his trip.

Where reports differ
Compiled from reports by Stuff, RNZ, NZ Herald, The Post, 1News and Otago Daily Times.
How they headlined it
-
StuffWayne Brown says democracy has 'had its day' (opens in new tab)
-
RNZ'Not working well': Wayne Brown calls for MMP rethink after China visit (opens in new tab)
-
NZ Herald -
The Post‘Get his facts right’: Wayne Brown fires back at David Seymour over election barb (opens in new tab)
-
1News'Ok, Boomer!' US ambassador's jibe at Auckland mayor over China remark (opens in new tab)
-
Otago Daily Times‘Ok, Boomer’: US ambassador fires shot at Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown (opens in new tab)