Experts call for MMP reform following 11-seat election overhang

NZ HeraldStuffThe PostRNZOtago Daily Times1NewsWednesday 18 November 2026 · 6 outlets · 10 reports · updated

In this story Christopher Luxon, National Party, Te Pāti Māori, The Conversation, Geoffrey Palmer

Photo: NZ Herald (opens in new tab)

A group of 46 electoral experts, including a former Prime Minister, has issued an open letter calling for urgent changes to the MMP system. The group is seeking a cross-party select committee inquiry after the 2026 election resulted in an 11-seat overhang. The Green Party has expressed support for the push to maintain proportionality.

Key facts

3 facts
  • 46 electoral and constitutional experts signed an open letter for MMP reformStuffThe Post
  • The 2026 election preliminary results indicated an 11-seat overhangStuffThe PostOtago Daily Times
  • The 11-seat overhang is the largest in MMP's 30-year historyThe Post

The full story

1 min read · 6 outlets

A group of 46 electoral and constitutional experts has signed an open letter calling for urgent changes to New Zealand's MMP voting system. The letter, titled "Keep the 'P' in MMP", follows preliminary results from the 2026 election showing an 11-seat overhang, the largest in the system's 30-year history.StuffThe PostOtago Daily Times

The experts argue the election results exposed a significant weakness, noting that the second-place party could receive six more MPs than the party with the most party votes. They warn that the current outcome is not proportional and could lead to voter disillusionment and lower trust in democracy.StuffThe PostNZ Herald

The signatories include former Prime Minister Sir Geoffrey Palmer, the chair of the 2023 Independent Electoral Review, and various constitutional academics. They are calling on all political parties to commit to adjusting the system's settings through an urgent select committee inquiry.StuffThe PostNZ HeraldRNZ

Proposed solutions include increasing the proportion of list MPs, combining the electorate and party votes, or adopting a German-style approach to limit overhangs. The Green Party has expressed support for a review, provided that Māori electorates and Te Tiriti o Waitangi are protected.StuffThe PostRNZ

How it developed

  • Wed 18 Nov, 12:23pmThe Green Party stated it supports the call for a review but insists Māori seats must be protected.The Post

Where reports differ

  • Reports differ on the cause of the National Party overhang, with one describing it as an organic result of electorate success while another attributes it to a campaign by Harry MowbrayThe PostRNZ

Compiled from reports by Stuff, The Post, NZ Herald, RNZ, Otago Daily Times and 1News.

How they headlined it

First reported by NZ Herald, Wed 18 Nov, 4:00am · 10 reports from 6 outlets over 26 hours
  1. NZ HeraldNZ Herald

    Election 2026: Electoral experts, former PM warn of need for changes to MMP after overhang results (opens in new tab)

  2. StuffStuff

    46 electoral experts sign open letter calling for MMP reform (opens in new tab)

  3. The PostThe Post

    Experts call for changes to, and urgent select committee inquiry, on MMP ‘weakness’ (opens in new tab)

  4. RNZRNZ

    'Not the way MMP was supposed to work': Experts urge politicians to act on overhang (opens in new tab)

  5. Otago Daily TimesOtago Daily Times

    How to fix our electoral system and return moral authority to our government (opens in new tab)

  6. 1News1News via RNZ

    'Keep the P in MMP': Experts urge politicians to act on overhang (opens in new tab)