Supreme Court reduces sentence for woman convicted of manslaughter
In this story High Court, Supreme Court

Jessica Mulford's prison sentence for the manslaughter of two-year-old Harlee-Rose Niven has been reduced from over five years to four years. The Supreme Court cited youth-related factors, including mental health issues and impulsivity, when making the decision. Mulford had previously been convicted for inflicting fatal abdominal injuries on the toddler.
Key facts
3 facts
The full story
1 min read · 4 outlets
The Supreme Court has quashed Jessica Mulford’s five-year, seven-month prison sentence and substituted a four-year term for the manslaughter of two-year-old Harlee-Rose Niven. The court found that the previous sentence did not sufficiently account for youth-related factors such as isolation, inexperience, impulsivity, and mental health issues. The new sentence follows a decision that the earlier strangulation incident should not have been treated as an aggravating factor that increased the starting point of the sentence.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
The toddler died on 9 April 2022 in Waikato Hospital from internal organ lacerations, including a split pancreas, after being found unresponsive and blue. The injuries were consistent with being stomped, kicked, or punched. While the mechanism of the fatal injuries remained unknown, the High Court heard the injuries were severe enough to cause unconsciousness within minutes.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Mulford became the child's primary caregiver in August 2021 at age 17 while living in Tauranga. A separate incident involving strangulation occurred in November 2021. The Supreme Court noted that had the strangulation been charged promptly, Mulford likely would have been dealt with in the Youth Court.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
The Supreme Court determined a four-year, nine-month starting point was more appropriate than the original seven-year starting point. After applying discounts for prior trauma and rehabilitation prospects, the term was reduced to four years.![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Where reports differ
Compiled from reports by Stuff, NZ Herald, RNZ and Otago Daily Times.
How they headlined it
-
StuffWoman who killed toddler has prison sentence cut by Supreme Court (opens in new tab)
-
NZ Herald -
RNZTeen stepmum who killed toddler wins Supreme Court appeal, has sentence reduced (opens in new tab)
-
Otago Daily TimesTeen stepmum who killed toddler wins appeal, has sentence reduced (opens in new tab)