Review finds police breached rules by allowing documentary crew into crime scenes

NZ Herald1NewsStuffOtago Daily TimesFriday 20 November 2026 · 4 outlets · 4 reports · updated

In this story Netflix

Photo: NZ Herald (opens in new tab)

An internal review led by Dame Julie Christie found police breached best practice by granting a documentary crew exclusive access to crime scenes. Despite objections from officers in charge, filmmakers entered the campsite and shooting scene before forensic examinations were finished. The review has resulted in 12 recommendations.

Key facts

4 facts
  • The documentary, titled The Marokopa Project, is being produced for Netflix by NHNZ Worldwide and Grain Media.NZ Herald
  • Tom Phillips was killed in a shootout with police on Te Anga Road in Waitomo on 8 September 2025.NZ Herald1NewsStuff
  • The internal review was written by Detective Inspector Shaun Vickers.Stuff
  • Access to the shooting scene was authorised by Acting District Commander Andrea McBeth.NZ Herald

The full story

1 min read · 4 outlets

An internal police review has found that a documentary crew was granted exclusive access to crime scenes related to the search for Tom Phillips, despite objections from officers in charge. The crew was permitted to film at the Te Anga Road shooting scene and the campsite where Phillips' children were found before forensic examinations were complete.NZ Herald1NewsStuffOtago Daily Times

On 9 September 2025, the day after Phillips was killed in a shootout, Dame Julie Christie and a cameraman were given 25 to 30 minutes of controlled access to the shooting scene. While Phillips' body had been removed, forensic evidence was still visible and key items, including an ATV and police vehicles, remained in situ.NZ Herald1NewsStuffOtago Daily Times

The filmmakers were also escorted to the campsite where the children had been located, where forensic work was also unfinished. Officers in charge of both scenes formally challenged the decision, noting that such access was "inconsistent with established best practice" and created additional scene-management risks.NZ Herald1NewsStuff

The review, led by Detective Inspector Shaun Vickers, concluded that while investigative integrity was not compromised, the arrangement exacerbated perceptions of unfair treatment toward mainstream media. Police executive director of media and communications Cass Carter stated that while the documentary did not compromise integrity, it "created conditions where integrity required protection".NZ Herald1NewsStuff

How it developed

  • Fri 20 Nov, 10:50amThe review detailed that the crew had previously been exposed to covert policing tactics, including intercepted communications and motion-activated cameras, during the investigation.Stuff

Where reports differ

  • One report identifies the Acting District Commander as Andrea McBeth, while another notes the access was authorised by the Acting District Commander without naming the individual.NZ Herald1NewsStuffOtago Daily Times

Compiled from reports by NZ Herald, 1News, Stuff and Otago Daily Times.

How they headlined it

First reported by NZ Herald, Fri 20 Nov, 10:23am · 4 reports from 4 outlets over 2 hours
  1. NZ HeraldNZ Herald

    Tom Phillips shooting: Documentary crew accessed scene before forensic examination finished (opens in new tab)

  2. 1News1News

    Officers challenged doco crew access to Marokopa shooting scene, campsite (opens in new tab)

  3. StuffStuff

    Police admit letting film crew into Tom Phillips crime scenes breached rules (opens in new tab)

  4. Otago Daily TimesOtago Daily Times

    Film crew let into fugitive Tom Phillips' camp before forensics finished (opens in new tab)