Rodney Stewart Smith named in Christchurch double murder case

The Press1NewsNZ HeraldStuffOtago Daily TimesMonday 12 October 2026 · 5 outlets · 6 reports · updated
Photo: 1News (opens in new tab)

Rodney Stewart Smith, 58, appeared in Christchurch District Court charged with two murders and attempted murder. The incident occurred at a social housing complex on Olliviers Road in Phillipstown on Saturday. Smith entered no pleas and was remanded in custody until his High Court appearance later this month.

Key facts

5 facts
  • Accused: Rodney Stewart Smith, 58, forklift operatorThe Press1NewsNZ HeraldOtago Daily Times
  • Victims: Glen Allan Tukaki and Nigel John RobinsonThe PressStuffOtago Daily Times
  • Location: Olliviers Road, Phillipstown, ChristchurchThe Press1NewsStuffOtago Daily Times
  • Date of incident: Saturday, 12.50amThe Press1NewsNZ HeraldStuffOtago Daily Times
  • Next court appearance: 29 October in High CourtThe Press1NewsNZ HeraldStuff

The full story

1 min read · 5 outlets

Rodney Stewart Smith, a 58-year-old forklift operator, appeared in Christchurch District Court on Monday facing two murder charges. He is also accused of attempting to murder James Alan Dell, wounding Shantay Marie McQuade with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, intentionally damaging the tyres of a car, and failing to assist a detective. Smith appeared via audiovisual link from prison and entered no pleas.The Press1NewsNZ HeraldStuffOtago Daily Times

The charges follow an incident at a social housing complex on Olliviers Road in Phillipstown around 12.50am on Saturday. Police found Glen Allan ‘Lizard’ Tukaki and Nigel John ‘Rooster’ Robinson dead at the scene. Two other people were also seriously injured during the incident.The Press1NewsStuffOtago Daily Times

Defence lawyer Andrew McKenzie stated that while Smith is the man named on the charge sheet, his client prefers to go by the name Fallowfield. Smith did not apply for interim name suppression or bail, and did not oppose media applications to use his photograph. Judge Tony Zohrab remanded Smith in custody to reappear in the High Court on 29 October.The Press1NewsNZ HeraldStuffOtago Daily Times

Detective Inspector Greg Murton stated that those involved in the incident were known to each other and that police believe the event was isolated. While Tukaki was a former president of the Devils Henchmen Motorcycle Club, Murton described the gang connection as “very historical” and not a factor in the investigation.The PressStuffOtago Daily Times

Where reports differ

  • The defendant's surname is reported as Smith, though his lawyer stated he prefers the name FallowfieldThe PressStuff

Compiled from reports by The Press, 1News, NZ Herald, Stuff and Otago Daily Times.

How they headlined it

First reported by The Press, Mon 12 Oct, 10:16am · 6 reports from 5 outlets over 4 hours
  1. The PressThe Press

    Christchurch double murder-accused named as Rodney Stewart Smith (opens in new tab)

  2. 1News1News

    Man in court charged with Christchurch double killing (opens in new tab)

  3. NZ HeraldNZ Herald

    Christchurch double homicide: 58-year-old man appears in court on murder charges (opens in new tab)

  4. StuffStuff

    Identity of man accused of double Christchurch murder revealed (opens in new tab)

  5. Otago Daily TimesOtago Daily Times

    Man accused of Christchurch double murder in court (opens in new tab)