Lon Reti's murder conviction referred back to Court of Appeal

NZ HeraldRNZOtago Daily TimesThe PostSunday 8 November 2026 · 4 outlets · 5 reports · updated

In this story Court of Appeal, Criminal Cases Review Commission

Photo: NZ Herald (opens in new tab)

Lon Reti is appealing his 1998 conviction for the 1997 murder of Leslie Edmonds in Christchurch. His lawyers argued in the Court of Appeal that his actions were triggered by sexual abuse experienced in state care. The case returned to court after a Crown entity reviewed his conviction.

Key facts

4 facts
  • Lon Reti convicted of murder in July 1998NZ HeraldOtago Daily Times
  • Leslie Edmonds killed in October 1997 in ChristchurchNZ HeraldOtago Daily TimesThe Post
  • Criminal Cases Review Commission began investigation in 2022NZ HeraldOtago Daily Times
  • Reti sentenced to life imprisonmentNZ HeraldOtago Daily Times

The full story

1 min read · 3 outlets

Lon Reti's 1998 murder conviction is being reviewed by the Court of Appeal after a Crown entity raised concerns regarding his original trial. The Criminal Cases Review Commission referred the case back after finding that expert evidence regarding Reti's mental health and history of abuse was not presented to the jury.NZ HeraldOtago Daily TimesThe Post

Reti was convicted of the October 1997 killing of Leslie Edmonds in a Christchurch squat. During the original trial, the partial defence of provocation was raised, but the commission found that new information was relevant to this defence.NZ HeraldOtago Daily Times

At the Court of Appeal on Monday, Reti's lawyer, Kerry Cook, KC, argued that Reti suffered from Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (CPTSD) due to horrific childhood abuse in state care. Cook stated that Reti's reaction to Edmonds' alleged sexual advances was a 'fight or flight' response triggered by this trauma.NZ HeraldThe Post

Lawyers for Reti are seeking to have the murder conviction quashed and replaced with a manslaughter verdict. One lawyer, Olivia Jarvis, suggested a sentence for manslaughter in the range of 10 to 12 years, which would likely result in Reti's immediate release.The Post

How it developed

  • Mon 9 Nov, 5:00pmThe Court of Appeal heard evidence that Reti has Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and suffered sexual abuse in state care.NZ Herald
  • Tue 10 Nov, 4:00amLawyers argued for a manslaughter conviction instead of murder and suggested a sentence of 10 to 12 years.The Post

Where reports differ

  • One report identifies the defendant as Lon Wilcox Reti, while others use Lon RetiNZ HeraldOtago Daily TimesThe Post

Compiled from reports by NZ Herald, Otago Daily Times and The Post.

How they headlined it

First reported by NZ Herald, Sun 8 Nov, 6:00pm · 5 reports from 3 outlets over 42 hours
  1. NZ HeraldNZ Herald

    Leslie Edmonds murder: Lon Reti conviction referred back to court after review (opens in new tab)

    Also on RNZ (opens in new tab)

  2. Otago Daily TimesOtago Daily Times

    Brutal 1997 Christchurch murder back before court after review raises serious questions (opens in new tab)

  3. The PostThe Post

    Murderer who severed victim’s ears makes bid for freedom (opens in new tab)