Chris Hipkins heckled by Vision NZ candidate at Ōtara markets

NZ HeraldStuffRNZOtago Daily TimesThe PostSaturday 26 September 2026 · 5 outlets · 6 reports · updated

In this story Labour Party, Chris Hipkins, Vision NZ, Trevor Mallard

Photo: NZ Herald (opens in new tab)

Labour leader Chris Hipkins was confronted by Vision NZ candidate Karl Mokaraka during a campaign visit to the Ōtara markets on Saturday. Mokaraka questioned Hipkins on the definition of a woman and criticised his record in South Auckland. Trevor Mallard reportedly intervened during the confrontation.

Key facts

5 facts
  • Karl Mokaraka is the Vision NZ candidate for the Ōtāhuhu electorateRNZ
  • The confrontation took place on a Saturday morning at the Ōtara MarketsNZ HeraldRNZ
  • The event occurred during heavy rainRNZOtago Daily Times
  • Mokaraka has previously heckled Hipkins at the same location in 2023RNZ
  • Hipkins met with stallholders who identified the cost of living as a primary issueOtago Daily Times

The full story

1 min read · 5 outlets

Labour leader Chris Hipkins was confronted by Vision NZ candidate Karl Mokaraka during a campaign visit to the Ōtara Markets on Saturday morning. The confrontation occurred as Hipkins was heading to his car in heavy rain. Mokaraka, who is standing as the Vision NZ candidate for the Ōtāhuhu electorate, repeatedly shouted "what's a woman?" and accused Hipkins of leaving South Auckland "in a mess".NZ HeraldRNZStuff

Former Labour Speaker Trevor Mallard intervened by stepping between the two men. During the intervention, Mallard appeared to bump into Mokaraka and told him, "stop that".NZ HeraldRNZStuff

Before the confrontation, Mokaraka appeared friendly and shook hands with Hipkins. Hipkins, who was accompanied by deputy Carmel Sepuloni and other local candidates, noted that the campaign could be conducted "quite civilly".StuffOtago Daily Times

The visit to the markets was part of a larger campaign day that included a rally at Waatea Marae in Māngere. Hipkins stated that winning Auckland is "really important" for the party and focused on increasing voter turnout.Otago Daily Times

How it developed

  • Sat 26 Sep, 2:48pmHipkins stated that winning Auckland is important for the party and noted that the Electoral Commission could improve voter enrolment.Otago Daily Times

Where reports differ

  • One report described the encounter as a brief altercation, while another noted Mokaraka appeared friendly and shook hands before the confrontation.NZ HeraldStuffRNZOtago Daily TimesThe Post

Compiled from reports by NZ Herald, Stuff, RNZ, Otago Daily Times and The Post.

How they headlined it

First reported by NZ Herald, Sat 26 Sep, 10:21am · 6 reports from 5 outlets over 8 hours
  1. NZ HeraldNZ Herald

    Karl Mokaraka heckles Chris Hipkins at Ōtara markets as Trevor Mallard steps in (opens in new tab)

  2. StuffStuff

    'What's a woman?': Hipkins heckled by Vision NZ candidate (opens in new tab)

  3. RNZRNZ

    'What's a woman?': Vision NZ's Karl Mokaraka heckles Chris Hipkins at Ōtara Markets (opens in new tab)

  4. Otago Daily TimesOtago Daily Times

    Labour's Chris Hipkins targets Auckland turnout ahead of campaign launch (opens in new tab)

    Also on RNZ (opens in new tab)

  5. The PostThe Post

    8000 door knocks, a league table and a bit of rain - inside the first weekend of the election campaign (opens in new tab)