High Court rules pay equity law changes discriminated against women

The PostNZ HeraldOtago Daily TimesStuff1NewsRNZThursday 19 November 2026 · 6 outlets · 9 reports · updated

In this story High Court, Brooke van Velden, Public Service Association

Photo: NZ Herald (opens in new tab)

The High Court has declared the Government's Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 inconsistent with the Bill of Rights. Justice Paul Radich found the urgent changes discriminated against women and were driven by financial savings. While the ruling identifies the breach, the law remains in force.

Key facts

4 facts
  • The High Court issued a declaration of inconsistency regarding the Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025.The PostNZ HeraldStuff
  • The 2025 amendments cancelled 33 active pay equity claims.The PostNZ HeraldStuff1News
  • The law changes were estimated to save $12.8 billion over four years.NZ HeraldStuff
  • Justice Paul Radich found the changes were driven by fiscal reasons rather than evidence the previous system was not working.The PostNZ HeraldStuff1News

The full story

1 min read · 6 outlets

The High Court has declared that the Government's 2025 overhaul of the Equal Pay Act was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act. Justice Paul Radich found the amendments discriminated against women in female-dominated occupations and were driven by fiscal motives rather than a need to fix a broken system.The PostNZ HeraldStuff1News

The amendments, which passed under urgency in May 2025, cancelled 33 active pay equity claims and made it more difficult to bring new claims. These changes are estimated to have saved the Government $12.8 billion over four years.The PostNZ HeraldStuff1News

The ruling does not overturn or invalidate the law, which remains in force. If the Crown does not appeal, the Attorney-General must inform Parliament of the declaration within six sitting days, after which a select committee will examine it and the Government must provide a formal response within six months.The PostNZ HeraldOtago Daily TimesRNZ

Unions representing nurses, teachers, public servants, and tertiary education staff brought the case to court.The PostNZ Herald1News

How it developed

  • Fri 20 Nov, 9:42amProfessor Dame Marilyn Waring noted that the ruling means Parliament will have to deal with both the declaration and a stalled petition.Otago Daily Times

Where reports differ

  • One report notes the changes raised the threshold for a female-dominated workforce from 60% to 70% for 10 years, while another focuses on the cancellation of claims.The Post1News

Compiled from reports by The Post, NZ Herald, Otago Daily Times, Stuff, 1News and RNZ.

How they headlined it

First reported by The Post, Thu 19 Nov, 1:59pm · 9 reports from 6 outlets over 24 hours
  1. The PostThe Post

    Judge finds pay equity law rewrite discriminates against women: ‘The reason was strictly financial’ (opens in new tab)

  2. NZ HeraldNZ Herald

    High Court finds pay equity overhaul breached Bill of Rights Act (opens in new tab)

  3. Otago Daily TimesOtago Daily Times

    Scrapping pay equity breached women's rights, High Court rules (opens in new tab)

  4. StuffStuff

    Rushed pay equity change breached human rights, court rules (opens in new tab)

  5. 1News1News via RNZ

    High Court rules Govt's pay equity scrapping breached women's rights (opens in new tab)

  6. RNZRNZ

    Parliament to deal with pay equity on two fronts, former National MP says (opens in new tab)